Skip to main content

Full text of "Numismatics International Bulletin, Vol. 21, No.7"

See other formats


23 


years 


of  service  to  numismatics 


NI 

BULLETIN 


[NUMISMATICS  INTERNATIONAL 


POUND  I 0 1**4 


Volume  2 1 Number  7 ISSN:  0197-3088  Price  ....  Two  Dollars 


1 * 

TABLE  OF  CONTENTS 


FEATURES 

An  Introduction  to  Byzantine  Coinage,  No.  26, 

by  I.  C.  G.  Campbell  163 

Chinese  Cloth  Currency,  by  R.  J.  Hebert  165 

The  Coins  of  Salta,  Argentina,  by  J.  Alma  Ott  168 

"LEO  VI  The  Wise  - He  Published  'The  Basilica"', 

by  Leo  Grossman  160 

Ottoman  Coins  Inscribed  With  a Religious  Title, 
by  Kenneth  M.  MaoXenzie  157 

DEPARTMENTS 

Book  Reviews  171 

Contents  of  the  NI  Reference  Collection ' 170 

From  the  Mailbox 155 

IDENTIFICATION,  Please?  162 

INFORMATION,  Please  162 

Member  Notice  Page  176 

INSIDE  N. I . 

Donations  Report  155 

Librarian's  Report  155 

Membership  Chairman's  Report  155 

OTHER  ITEMS 

The  Argentine  Republic  1975  One  Peso  Pattern,  by  J.  Alma  Ott  - 159 

Bal ista  175 

"Bigati"  and  "Quadrigati"  Coinage  176 

Congiaria  167 

Denarius  Symbolizes  Filial  Piety  176 

Diety  Coins  of  Augustus  Struck  by  Rome  Mint 167 

"Exagium  Sol idi " 162 


Copyrighted  by  Numismatics  International,  P.O.  Box  670013,  Dallas,  Texas  USA  75367-0013 


JULY  1987 


BOARD  OF  GOVERNORS 


WM.  B.  THOMPSON 
Chairman  & Past  President 

C.C.  ANDREWS  ROBERT  W.  RICHTER 

President  Vice-President 

214-357-1379 


ROSS  SCHRAEDER 
Secretary 


DON  C.  DOUGLAS 
At- Large- Director 


CHARLES  MUCHMORE 
Treasurer 

LEE  GROSSMAN 
At- Large-Director 


WILLIAM  E.  BENSON 
MARVIN  L.  FRALEY 
JACK  E.  LEWIS 
JOHN  E.  VANDIGRIFF 


KARY  T.  EDWARDS 
PHILIP  L.  LAWRENCE 
ELMORE  B.  SCOTT 
CARL  YOUNG 


Past-Presidents 


APPOINTED  STAFF 


Curator,  Nl  REFERENCE  COLLECTION 
Philip  L.  Lawrence 

Curator,  JOHN  GRAVES  MEMORIAL 
PAPER  MONEY  COLLECTION 
David  Block 
P.  O.  Box  12473 
Gainesville,  Florida  32602 

Editor,  Nl  BULLETIN 
Marvin  L.  Fraley,  N.L.G. 

2813  - 57th  St. 

Lubbock,  Texas  79413 
Phone  - 806-795-7623 

Article  Editor,  Nl  BULLETIN 
Fred  Drost,  N.L.G. 

1 10  Ridgefield  St. 

Meriden,  Connecticut  06450 
Phone  - 203-235-7565 

Book  News  & Reviews  Editor, 

Nl  BULLETIN 

Raymond  J.  Hebert 
6305  Windermere  Circle 
Rockville,  MD  20852 

Article  Abstractor,  Nl  BULLETIN 
Joseph  Uphoff 
La  Jolla,  California 

Index  Compiler,  Nl  BULLETIN 
Dick  Schubert 
Denver,  Colorado 

Publicity  Chairman 
Stuart  T.  Eisen 
Phone  - 301-530-5400 


Librarian,  Nl  BOOK  LIBRARY 
Granvyl  G.  Hulse,  Jr. 

30  Pleasant  St. 

Colebrook,  N H.  03576 

Librarian,  Nl  CATALOG  SUB-LIBRARY 
Donald  H.  Mead 
323  N Estelle 
Wichita,  Kansas  67214 

Librarian,  Nl  PERIODICAL  LIBRARY 
Jim  Haley 
P.O.  Box  4057 
St.  Johnsbury,  VT  05819 

Mail  Bid  Sales 
Carl  Young 
P.  O.  Box  1836 
Dallas,  Texas  75221 

Nl  Publications  Chairman 
Randolph  Zander 

N.I.C.E.  General  Chairman 
Charles  Muchmore,  Jr. 

P.  O.  Box  6094 
Richardson,  Texas  75080 

Photographer,  Nl  BULLETIN 
Dick  Hanscom 
P.  O.  Box  2832 
Fairbanks,  Alaska  99707 

Moderator,  N.l.  EDUCATIONAL  PROGRAM 
William  F.  Spengler 
2032  Ridgeway 
Colorado  Springs,  CO  80906 


Correspondence  should  be  directed  to  those  persons  and  addresses  above  for  depart- 
ments indicated  All  other  correspondence  should  be  mailed  direct  to  NUMISMATICS 
INTERNATIONAL,  P.  O.  Box  670013,  DALLAS,  TX  75367-0013 

MEMBERSHIP  FEE:  Individual  & Club  Membership  - $15.00  Annually.  Junior  Member- 
ship (18  years  of  age  and  under)  - $10.00  Annually.  Senior  Membership  (70  years  of  age  and 
over)  - $10.00  Annually. 


154 


INSIDE  N.l. 

M EMB_E  H IP  _ CH  A I RM AN  ' S_  RE!PQRT 

No  Applications  for  Membership  were  received  since  the  last  report. 
Any  members  needing  materials  for  recruitinn  are  uroed  to  write  to 
the  Membership  Chairman  requesting  same. 


LIFE!  MEMBERSHIPS 


Life  Memberships  are  available  to  members  of  three  years'  standing 
upon  application  to  the  Board  of  Governors  and  the  payment  of  the 
$200.00  fee.  Conditional  Life  Membership  is  available  upon  payment 
of  $60.00  down  and  four  quarterly  payments  of  $35.00. 

***** 


DONATIONS  RE!P0RT 


The  following  donations  have  been  received  since  the  last  report. 


Name 


Donation 


Preference  of  Use 


CANNIT0,  R.  A 
HEiBEERT , R.  J. 
LEWIS , J.  E . 
MAIE!R , Mike 


129  Coins  ($1917.00) 
250  Coins  (NVS) 

742  Coins  ($3944.00) 
33  Coins  ($22.20) 


NI  Reference  Collection 
NI  Reference  Collection 
NI  Reference  Collection 
NI  Reference  Collection 


NVS  = No  Value  Stated  by  donor 


★ ★★★★ 


LIBRARIAN'S  RLPORT 

I.  Acknowledement  is  made  below  to  those  who  have  donated  material 
to  the  NI  Library: 

The  Author 

JF95.BezR;1980:DCP 

EZfiRRA,  RUBIENS  B0RGFS 

Dutch  Coins  in  Pernambuco 
Pub.  1980,  1 36pp , w/plates, 

Thomas  Hi  gel 

BD70.BooH:1986 :CKZ 
BOOK,  HE!LEN 

Coins  of  Kilwa  and  Zanzibar  in  Medieval  East  Africa 

Pub.  1986,  24pp , illus. 

Dr.  Michael  Robinson 


155 


J 1 6 7 . Ne  u J ;R987 : ICCT 
NEUMANN,  JOSEF 

Italian  copper  coins  and  tokens 

Extracted  and  re-printed  in  1987  by  Dr.  Robinson  from  Josef  Neu- 
mann's work  Beschreihung  der  Bekanntesten  kupfermunzen . ca360pp, 
w/plates . 

Ingrid  K.  Smith 


WD50 . FraM : 1987 : CCC 

FRAGINALS,  MANUEL  MORENO/LEDESMA,  JOSE  A.  PULIDO 
Cuba , a country  and  its  currency 
Pub.  1987,  221 pp , i 11  us . 

A.  G.  van  der  Dussen 


JF90.DupC:R986 :MMJM 
DUPREIZ , CHARLES 

Monnaies,  medailles,  jetons  et  mereaux  - Liege. 

A 1986  reprint  of  catalog  No.  101  of  1910  devoted  to  coins  of 
Liege.  20pp,  w/plates. 

JF90.MigA:1986:MPL 
MIGNOLET,  ANDRE 

Les  monnaies  de  la  principaute  de  Liege.  Description  com- 
mentee  des  monnaies  gravees  dans  l 'ouvrage  du  baron  de 
Chestret  de  Haneffe. 

An  updated  re-print  of  baron  de  Chestret  de  Haneffe 's  original 
1887  presentation  to  the  Royal  Academy  of  Belgium.  130pp,  w/plates. 

II.  In  addition  to  the  above  donations  we  would  like  to  thank  Thomas 
A.  Schillinger  for  the  donation  of  additional  numismatic  material  to 
the  NI  Library. 


Granvyl  G.  Hulse,  Jr. 

NI  Book  Librarian 

*★***★★★***★★*  *★****★★**★**★  **********************  **■*•*★*★**■****■*  **★*■*•* 
FROM  THE  MAILBOX 

(Ed.  The  following  letter  was  written  to  NI  member  John  L,  Pieratt 
by  Diane  Wolf  of  The  Commission  of  Fine  Arts  giving  information  on 
the  Vietnam  National  Medal.) 

Dear  Mr.  Pieratt: 

In  regard  to  your  inquiry  about  the  Vietnam  National  Medal,  the  obverse 
was  designed  by  Corporal  Terrill  K,  Tritch  of  the  U.S,  Army  and  the 
reverse  by  James  Peed,  a U.  S.  Mint  employee,  The  medal  is  available 
in  bronze  in  two  sizes.  The  3"  medal  sells  for  $16;  the  1 1/2"  for 
$2.25.  (These  are  mail  order  prices.)  You  purchase  the  afore  describ- 
ed medals  by  writing  to  the  following  address; 

The  Vietnam  Vets  National  Medal 
The  U.  S.  Mint 
P.  0.  Box  500 

Philadelphia,  Pennzylvania  19105 
/s/  Diane  Wolf 


156 


OTTOMAN  COINS  INSCRIBED 


WITH  A RELIGIOUS  TITLE 


Kenneth  M.  Mac  Kenzie , Tenafly , NJ. 

The  principal  religious  title  khadim  al^-Haramayn  al^Sharifayn  (servant 
of  the  noble  sanctuaries)  was  assumed  by  Sultan  Selim  I ( Yavuz  = "the 
Grim")  in  1517  (AH  922)  after  he  conquered  Egypt  and  deposed  the  last 
Abbasid  Caliph  in  Cairo.  The  title  was  not  used  by  the  Abbasids, 
but  although  not  standard,  was  used  by  many  Mamluk  Sultans,  the  first 
being  Salah  al-din  & also  by  a number  of  other  Muslim  rulers. 


The  religious  title  written  out 
in  precise , flowing  Arabic  by 
Mr.  MacKenzie. 

Selim  received  the  keys  of  the  two  holy  cities  (Makkah  and  Medina) 
from  the  sherif  of  Makkah  on  July  3rd,  1517,  thus  giving  him  control. 

He  was  promptly  made  the  sherif  governor  of  the  new  provinces  of  Jeddah 
and  the  Hijaz  as  well  as  the  cities  of  Makkah  and  Medina,  thereby  es- 
tablishing a precedent  for  his  successors. 

The  chief  duty  of  the  servant  (Khadim)  is  the  protection  of  the 
two  most  revered  sanctuaries  in  Islam,  the  Ka'aba  surrounding  the 
Grand  Mosque  in  Makkah,  and  the  tomb  of  the  prophet  in  Medina.  This 
included  the  maintenance  of  the  fabric  of  the  buildings  and  to  facili- 
tate the  Hag j - the  pilgrimage  of  the  faithful  to  the  shrines.  The 
Ottoman  sultans  faithfully  carried  out  these  duties  with  few  inter- 
ruptions until  the  last  sultan,  Mehmed  VI,  was  deposed  in  November  of 
1922,  Subsequently  the  rulers  of  Saudi  Arabia  inherited  the  office. 

We  do  not  have  coins  inscribed  with  this  religious  title  until  the 
Sultan  Suleyman  I ( Kanuni  - "the  1 awgi ver" ),  known  in  the  west  as 
The  Magnificent,  was  enthroned  upon  the  death  of  his  father  Selim  I 
by  cancer  in  September  1520.  Suleyman  ruled  for  46  years  during 
which  time  he  doubled  his  vast  territories,  while  accompanying  his 
army  on  thirteen  campaigns. 

During  his  second  expedition,  June  1522/AH  928  - January  1523/AH  929, 
he  took  the  island  of  Rhodes,  which  had  been  an  outpost  of  Christian- 
ity, where  pirates  harboured  and  raided  the  Ottoman  controlled  seas. 
They  captured  ships  which  brought  grain  and  gold  from  the  new  Arab 
provinces  and  carried  pilgrims  to  and  from  the  holy  cities  of  Makkah 
and  Medina.  After  his  return  to  Constantinople  a large  silver  coin 
was  struck  called  gumus  sultaniye  (silver  sultanti,  after  the  pop- 
ular gold  coin  in  use);  it  was  sometimes  referred  to  as  Muhammad  Khani 
and  was  of  10  akce  value,  dated  930  with  the  legend  on  the  obverse: 


157 


Khadim  al-Havamayn  al-Shavifayn  Sultan  al  bavvayn  wa'l-bahvayn.  C1J  Sim- 
ilar 10  ak re  coins  were  struck  in  Constantinople  C2J  and  Novar  C3H  by 
Sultan  Mehmed  II  (1470/AH875)  and  by  his  son  Sultan  Bayezid  II  (1481/ 

AH  886)  in  Constantinople  cU:,  but  their  legends  did  not  include  the 
religious  title. 

On  his  sixth  expedition,  Suleyman  marched  against  the  Persian  shah 
(1534/AH  941  and  conquered  'Irak,  taking  Baghdad  where  he  stayed  for 
some  months  and  visited  the  nearby  cities  of  a 1 -Hi  11a  and  Karbala  where 
shrines  revered  bv  the  Sunnis  and  Shi  ' as  were  located.  Coins  were  then 
struck  in  Baghdad  and  al-Hilla.  The  altunl 53  gold  coin  had  the  obverse 
legend : Su l tan  al-barrayn  wa’l  bahrayn  abu'l  muzaffav  Suley- 
man Shah  bin  Salim  Shah  khadim  al-Havamayn  al-Shavifayn. 

On  the  reverse:  Khallada  Allah  ta’ola  malkuh  was  sultaniih 
wa-afada  'ala  al-’alamin  buvvuh  wa-ihsanuh.  The  silver 
dirhem  c6:  was  similar  except  "abu'l  muzaffav"  was  omitted  on  the 
obverse,  and  the  reverse  slightly  changed  with  "ta'ola"  omitted.  The 
Safavids  under  Tahmasp  I once  had  possession  of  the  mint  which  may 
explain  the  use  of  certain  words  in  the  legends  which  were  not  in  use 
on  Ottoman  coins. 

At  al-Hilla  the  divhem  C T □ and  altun  C8:  were  struck  with  the 
legend  on  the  reverse  - _Sultan  al-bavvayn  wa'l  bahvayn  khadim 
al-Havamayn  al-Shavifayn : and  on  the  obverse : Al-Sultan  _al- 
'adil  al  kamil  abu'l  muzaffav  Suleyman  Shah  bin  Salim  Khan. 
The  names  of  the  rulers  and  the  mint  being  contained  in  cartouches 
after  the  style  of  the  Safavid  coins. 

Under  the  Ottoman  Sultan  Murad  III  another  invasion  of  Persia  was 
launched  after  the  death  of  the  old  Shah  Tamasp  in  1578.  To  pay  for 
the  costs  of  this  expedition  the  silver  mines  in  Janja  in  the  province 
of  Trabzon  produced  divhems\L91  acceptable  in  the  East.  On  these 
silver  coins  the  legends  were  typically  Ottoman  but  with  a shortened 
version  of  the  religious  title  on  the  reverse:  Sultan  al-bavvayn 
wa  Khaqan  al-bahvayn  khadim  al-Havamayn  wa-sultan.  Murad's 
accession  date  of  982  appeared  only  on  these  coins. 

In  so  far  as  the  non-Ottoman  coins  are  concerned,  gold  coins  bearing 
the  religious  title  were  struck  by  Suleyman  cio:,  the  son  of  Mirza 
Khan  (of  Badakhshan),  who  reigned  until  1583/AH  983,  at  which  time  he 
was  driven  out  by  his  grandson.  He  retired  first  to  India  then  t.o 
Makkah,  where  he  may  have  been  inspired  to  adopt  the  title  for  his 
coins.  These  were  struck  after  he  returned  to  his  own  country  that  same 
year,  prior  to  its  capture  by  the  Ozbegs  in  the  following  year. 

Finally  in  Saudi  Arabia  a fine  gold  medal  was  struck  by  the  King,  Fahd 
bin  Abdul  Abdul  Aziz  who  came  to  the  throne  in  May  1982.  It  is  dated 
9 Sa'far  1405  AH  (1984)  and  the  religious  title  as  discussed  is  en- 
graved above  the  head  of  the  king  on  the  obverse. 

Incidentally.  P.  Kilborn,  in  a dispatch  from  the  New  York  Times 
(February  13th  1987,  page  All)  entitled:  "In  a land  of  Palaces 
s.ays  Late  last  year  King  Fahd  told  his  supplicants  and  all 

other  Saudis  to  stop  addressing  him  as  'Your  Majesty'  and  instead  say 
'Custodian  of  the  Two  Holy  Places  (Mecca  and  Medina)'.  Dutifully  the 
Saudi  Press  now  so  identifies  him  on  all  references.  If  cumbersome 
in  English,  it's  easier  to  say  in  Arabic  ...  ." 


158 


References  to  the  coins  mentioned: 


1.  Artuk  (I)  Kanuni  Sultccn  Suleyman  Adina  Basilan  Sikkeler  (1972) 

No.  15  7.50  or.  24  mm. 

2.  Pere  (N)  Osmanlilarda  Madeni  Paralar  (1968).  No.  82  8.32  or. 

3.  " " " No.  83  9.36  or. 

4.  " " " No.  104  7.75  or. 

5.  " " No.  160 

6.  Artuk  (I)  Kanuni  Sultan  Suleyman  Adina  Basilan  Sikkeler  (1972) 

No.  63  4.30  or. 

7.  Bulletin  ('Turkish  Numismatic  Society )3  #17  (1985) 

Coin  in  Collection  of  C.  Ol^er.  (page  8) 

8.  Ghalip  (I)  Taqvvm-i  Meskukat-i  'OsmUmye  (1890)  No.  982 

9.  " " No.  369 

10.  Edhem  (H)  Meskukat-i  Kadime-i  Islamiye  Katalotfu,  vi.3  (1915) 

Nos.  1264/5/6. 

11.  Lane-Pool e (S)  Catalogue  of  Oriental  Coins 3 vol.  viii3  (1883) 

No.  210  (with  word  "champion"  added). 

**************************^*****************************  ******  ***-*■*■*■** 

THE  ARGENTINE  REPUBLIC  1975  ONE  PESO  PATTERN 

J.  Alma  Ott,  Provo,  Utah,  NI  § 2145 

In  the  years  1974  to  1976  Argentina  struck  a One  Peso  coin  for  circul- 
ation with  the  well-known  Argentine  sunface  below  "REPUBLICA  ARGENTINA" 
on  the  obverse,  and  a tassel  to  the  left  of  the  value  indication  with 
the  date  below  on  the  reverse.  It  was  struck  at  the  Buenos  Aires  Mint, 
is  22.3mm  in  diameter  and  weighs  5 grams.  It  is  made  of  brass  and 
aluminum  and  has  a reeded  edge. 

In  1975  the  Republic  struck  a pattern  of  this  coin  with  the  difference 
being  having  tassels  on  both  sides  of  the  value  indication  and  date 
on  the  reverse.  The  other  designs  and  specifications  of  this  pattern 
are  the  same  as  the  coins  struck  for  general  circulation. 


Circulation  Reverse  Obverse  Pattern  Reverse 


The  mintage  of  this  pattern  is  unknown,  although  it  is  known  to  have 
been  struck  in  relative  abundance  as  far  as  some  patterns  go.  I have 
seen  a few  for  sale  for  A 35.00  (Australes)  - or  about  $23.00  U.S. 

Note : The  enlarged  photos  are  of  coins  from  the  author's  private 
coTTection . 


159 


"LEO  VI  The  Wise 


HF  PUB  LI  SEEL  'THE  BASILICA'" 


Lee  Grossman 3 NLG 3 San  Antonio 3 Texas } A II  A 1707 


Basil  (Basilius)  was  a Macedonian  peasant,  who  worked  his  way  up  to 
being  a groom  at  the  imperial  court  of  Byzantine  Emperor  Michael  III. 
It  wasn't  long  before  the  emperor  and  Basil  became  friends.  Basil  had 
Bardas,  Michael's  Caesar,  murdered,  and  forced  Michael  to  make  him  co- 
emperor. The  ambitious  Basil  eventually  killed  his  mentor  on  Septem- 
ber 23,  867  AD. 


Leo's  FoVlis  from  Constantinople  Mint 

I haven't  been  able  to  find  any  evidence  that  Michael  had  a wife  (or 
mistress)  named  Eudocia  Ingerina  nor  have  I read  about  Basil's  first 
wife.  History  only  shows  that  Eudocia  was  Basil's  second  wife. 

LEO  VI  is  recorded  as  being  the  eldest  son  of  Byzantine  Emperor  Basil 
the  First  and  Eudocia  Ingerina.  Yet  my  research  points  out  that  their 
first-born  was  Constantine  (who  died  in  877  AD),  followed  by  Leo  and 
Alexander.  Some  historians  have  written  that  Michael  III  was  the 
father  of  Leo,  and  that  Michael  and  Eudocia  were  married  prior  to  her 
marriage  to  Basil.  Since  I'm  unable  to  substantiate  those  "facts", 

I'm  a bit  doubtful  as  to  their  veracity.  Although  Leo  was  co-emperor 
from  January  6,  870,  there  was  never  any  closeness  between  Basil  and 
Leo. 

Basil  had  become  very  active  in  jurisprudence  and  he  set  out  to  com- 
pletely revise  the  law  books  of  Justinian.  The  revision  was  never 
published  by  Basil . 

Leo  VI  succeeded  to  the  purple  on  August  26,  886,  when  Basil  died  fol- 
lowing a hunting  accident.  Leo  appointed  his  younger  brother,  Alexan- 
der, co -emperor. 

Having  the  reputation  for  learning  and  being  a scholar,  Leo  was  called 
"The  Wise,"  "Sapiens,"  and  "The  Philosopher."  He  oublished  the  great 
legal  works  that  Basil  had  started,  under  the  title  of  "The  Basilica." 
The  monumental  publication  was  written  in  Greek  instead  of  Latin,  and 
became  the  basis  of  law  in  Europe  for  centuries  to  come. 

Leo's  reign  was  not  a bed  of  roses,  as  he  devoted  most  of  his  time  to 
scholastics  and  paid  no  attention  to  foreign  affairs.  The  empire  began 
a rapid  decline.  When  Symeon  became  the  ruler  of  the  Bulgarians,  they 
became  very  agressive,  although  they  and  the  Byzantines  had  been  on 


160 


friendly  terms  for  some  time.  The  Saracens  picked  this  time  to 
move  into  Cilicia  and  "the  Aegean  Sea  was  full  of  their  fleets".  In 
902,  Sicily  fell  after  the  capture  of  Taormina,  Byzantium's  last 
stronghold  on  the  island,  and  Leo  pledaed  an  annual  tribute  to  the 
Bulaarians  to  keep  peace  in  the  Balkans. 

Leo  married  four  times  before  his  fourth  wife,  Zoe,  gave  birth  to  a 
male  heir  to  his  throne  in  905.  It  made  Leo  very  hapoy  and  he  named 
his  son  Constantine.  The  son  would  later  become  Emperor  Constantine 
VII.  In  his  Quest  for  a son  (via  four  marriages),  Leo  incurred  the 
wrath  of  the  Church  and  Patriarch  Nicholas  Mysticos,  and  he  was  banned 
from  entering  the  Church  of  St.  Sophia. 

Leo  VI  died  on  May  11,  912  AD.  His  heir,  Constantine,  was  a minor  of 
only  seven  years  of  age,  so  it  was  necessary  to  make  Alexander,  Leo's 
co-emperor  since  886,  the  ruler  of  the  empire. 

Coinage  of  Leo  VI  was  struck  at  the  mints  of  Constantinople  and  Cherson 
(in  the  Crimea),  although  David  R.  Sear  says  there  was  also  an  Uniden- 
tified Mint.  Three  different  Gold  Solidii;  two  different  Silver  Mi  1 i a - 
rense,  and  three  different  Bronze  Folles  were  issued  from  the  Constan- 
tinople mint.  The  Cherson  mint  issued  four  different  Bronze  coins, 
and  Sear  reports  a Bronze  Foil  is  and  a bronze  Half-Foil  is  were  minted 
at  an  uncertain  Provincial  mint.  According  to  Seth  W.  Stevenson,  "The 
bronze  (brass)  are  rare;  the  silver  still  rarer,  and  the  gold  most 
rare."  Most  of  Leo's  coinage  is  available  and  affordable. 

My  coin  is  a Bronze  Foil  is  in  Very  Fine  condition,  and  is  listed  as 
SEAR  1729.  The  obverse  has  the  bust  of  Leo,  facing  front,  with  a 
short  beard,  wearing  a crown  and  chlamys,  and  holding  an  akakis  in  his 
left  hand.  Around  the  bust  is  the  legend:  " + L£0>t  bMiutVs  ftcon" 
("LEO,  KING  OF  THE  ROMANS").  The  reverse  has  four  lines : L£oh/ 

b A /$■  | l £/o/V!6oh“("LEC,  BY  THE  GRACE  OF  GOD,  KING  OF  THE 

ROMANS"). 

GLOSSARY: 


CHLAMYS  - A short  military  cloak  worn  over  a cuirass.  It  was  fastened 
with  a buckle  on  the  right  shoulder,  leaving  arm  movements  free. 
AKAKIS  - A stiff  roll  of  parchment  covered  with  cloth  and  containing 
dust  to  symbolize  mortality.  The  roll  signifies  the  emperor's  final 
word  of  authority. 

A representation  of  the  Virgin  Mary  was  introduced  for  the  first  time 
on  Byzantine  coinage.  It  was  on  a Gold  Solidus,  with  the  emperor 
wearing  a long  beard,  and  the  Virgin  Mary,  shown  half-length,  with  her 
hands  lifted  up  in  prayer.  The  reverse  was  inscribed  with  the  name 
Maria  and,  in  the  field,  on  either  side,  was  0~~U  " 

("MOTHER  OF  GOD"). 

REFERENCES: 

BYZANTINE  COIN  VALUES  - Dr.  Paul  F.  Rynearson  (Malter-Westerfield  '71) 
COINS  OF  TEE  WORLD  — VOL.  2 - Dr.  Robert  A.G.  Carson  (Radius  Book/ 
Hutchinson),  1971 

A DICTIONARY  OF  ROMAN  COINS  - Seth  W.  Stevenson  (Seaby,  1982  reprint 
of  1889  original  volume) 


161 


BYZANTINE  COINS  & THEIR  VALUES  - David  R.  Sear  (Seaby,  London,  1974) 
ALL  RIGHTS  RESERVED.  (Vol . II  - "Heads  & Tails"  #104) . 
*******************************************  ******  ***************  ****** 

INFORMATION,  Please 


Information  on  Tonkin  "NOUVEAU  METAL  TONKINOISE"  located 

Fox-Pieratt  published  a request  for  help  on  the  Member  Notice  Page 
(April,  1987)  regarding  satirical  Tonkin  5 & 100  Francs,  The  follow- 
ing information  has  been  garnered  and  was  published  in  Paul  Bosco's 
May,  1987  list. 

3055  TONKIN.  Satirical  5 Francs  shellcard.  ca,1890.  37mm, 

issued  silvered.  Couple  spots,  else  VF-EF,  silvering 
mostly  intact,  (Photo)  *($75^200) 

designed  in  imitation  of  the  Ceres  Head  5 Francs.  Intended 
to  mock  France's  colonial  policy,  which  some  saw  as  a 
boondoggle.  At  a time  when  New  Caledonian  nickel  was  being 
aggressively  promoted,  this  piece's  legend  is  "NOUVEAU  METAL 
TONKINOISE" . The  value  reads  "5F  POUR  RIRE" : "rire"  trans- 

lates "to  laugh".  The  cataloger  has  heard  of  a 100  Francs 
satirical  but  has  only  seen  this  one  piece  offered.  Obvious- 
ly, the  piece  was  not  made  to  be  used  in  the  Orient,  but 
in  the  homeland. 

Fox-Pieratt  also  indicated  another  NI  member  had  both  of  the  denomin- 
ations, but  did  not  have  any  further  information  on  them, 

********************************************************************** 


IDENTIFICATION, 


Please? 


F,  M,  Orlowski  recently  submitted  the  follpwing  query; 


"For  the  past  few  years  I have  had  a small  paper  kreigsgeld  piece 
stamped  '20  pfennig  Stadt  Kiew' , on  three  lines.  This  piece  is  58  x 
65mm  and  has  heen  cut  from  the  lower  left  corner  of  a Russian  100 
ruble  of  1910,  Pick  #13,  in  the  1980,  3rd  edition.  This  is  the  area 
showing  the  serial  number,  the  number,  l1Q0',  in  the  design,  Could  it 
be  city  notgeld?" 


Can  anyone  provide  information  on  this  piece? 


********************************************************************** 


"EXAGIUM  S0LIDI 11 


A weight  used  to  test  the  legitimate  weight  of  the  solidus  during  the 
latter  Roman  Empire  was  called  "Exagius  Solidi".  Some  of  these  weights 
used  at  the  time  of  the  three  Emperors,  Honorius,  Arcadius  and  Theo- 
dosius II,  has  in  their  legend  "DDD  NNN  AAAVVVGGG"  for  "Domini  Nostri 
Augusti",  thus  denoting  the  three  emperors. 

(Submitted  by  R.  R.  Kutcher) 


162 


AN  INTRODUCTION  JO  BYZANTINE  COINAGE 

I.  C,  G.%  Campbell f Lincoln,  Nebraska } NI  #LMt15 


No.  26  r MICHAEL  I RHANGABE  (811-813) 


Michael's  brief  reign  was  a disaster.  He  associated  his  son  Theophy-r 
lactus  with  himself  almost  at  once  and  he  reversed  the  policies  of  his 
predecessor  both  for  iconoclasm  and  economy.  His  one  good  deed  was  to 
provide  for  the  families  of  those  killed  at  Markellen  - most  unusual 
in  those  times. 

He  recognized  the  Western  Empire  of  Charlemagne,  though  it  probably 
made  no  difference.  The  Bulgarians,  under  the  fearful  Krum,  were 
soon  ravaging  the  empire  and  approached  the  capital.  All  Michael 
could  do  was  to  resort  to  prayer.  Plague  broke  out  in  the  Bulgarian 
army  and  it  withdrew.  Krum  soon  returned,  defeating  the  larger  Byzan- 
tine army  due,  in  part,  to  the  treachery  of  Leo  the  Armenian  whom 
Michael  had  unwisely  recalled.  The  emperor  fled  and  left  Leo  in 
charge  of  what  was  left  of  the  army.  Leo  then  assumed  the  purple 
while  Michael  spent  the  next  32  years  as  the  monk  Athanasius  on  Platea, 
today  called  Hayrsiz,  one  of  the  smaller  of  the  Princes  Islands.  It 
was  also  called  Bulwers  after  a British  ambassador  who  built  a house 
there  in  the  last  century.  (We  used  to  go  there  sometimes  for  the 
annual  school  picnic.)  Michael's  younger  son  became  the  famous 
Patriarch  Ignatius,  on  of  the  few  Byzantine  stories  without  a bloody 
ending! 


Two  mints  struck  coins  for  this  brief  reign,  the  copper  folles  being 
tolerably  common.  The  faces  are  still  stylised. 


Rev , Miliaresion 
Constantinople 

GOLD;  Constantinople  records  just  the  one  type  of  solidus,  rare,  with 
Michael  on  the  obverse  and  Theophyl actus  on  the  reverse.  Legends  are: 


The  readings  are  not  always  clear. 

Syracuse  has  two  varieties  of  the  solidus,  the  first  excessively  rare 
and  the  other  very  rare, 

a)  Bust  of  Michael  on  either  side,  the  legends  known  being 


The  Coinage 


The  only  silver  coin  was  the  miliaresion  of  Con- 
stantinople. As  usual  this  had  as  obverse  the 
Cross  Potens  and  on  the  reverse  the  legend  for  both 
rulers  in  six  lines. 


+miXA 

HLseeoFV 

LAcr-eece 

bASILISKO 

mAioh 


Obv.  miXAHL  bASILtf.' 

Rev,  ©gofvlaCo  os  oesp' 


indi stinct. 


163 


b)  A bust  of  Michael  on  the  obverse  with  hdixahl  i,a  The 
reverse  has  a bust  of  Theophylactus  and  a blundered  legend. 

Syracuse  again  struck  the  semissis  (in  two  types)  and  the  tremissis, 
all  of  which  are  less  rare. 


Semissi s . 


a)  Bust  of  Michael  on  the  obverse.  Legend:  mix  ahl  bASiL  . 

Bust  of  Michael  on  the  reverse.  Legend:  ,7^  -p^pQ-^ 

b)  Obverse  as  a)  but  with  the  legend:  mi  xahl  bA  . 

Reverse  - Beardless  Theophylactus  with  legend:  nr  r*  £0<$  l A* 


b)  Syracuse  Semissis 
Michae l/Theophy lactus 


Syracuse  Tremissis 
Michael  both  sides 


There  is  only  one  type  of  tremissis  from  Syracuse,  The  obverse  is 
the  same  as  the  semissis  type  a).  The  reverse  agains  shows  Michael 
with  the  legend:  mi  XAHL'oe. 

BRONZE:  Constantinople  has  two  types  of  follis. 


Constantinople  Follis,  Type  a)  Syracuse  Follis,  Type  b). 

a)  Bust  of  Michael  facing,  with  legend:  miXA  hl  bA 

Reverse:  The  large  M with^ below  and  between  X/X/X  and  N/N/N. 

b)  Has  facing  busts  of  Michael  and  his  son,  with  the  legend: 
fDIXAHL  S ©60F  • 

The  reverse  is  the  same  as  type  a). 

Syracuse  also  has  two  types  of  follis. 

a)  Facing  bust  of  Michael  on  each  side,  wearing  the  loros  on 
the  obverse  and  the  chlamys  on  the  reverse.  The  reverse 
has  M left  of  the  bust  and  I/X/A  to  the  right. 

b)  The  obverse  is  as  a)  but  the  reverse  has  a bust  of  Theophy- 
lactus and  the  legend:  ee<t>ov. 

Note:  Reading  of  the  legends  is  often  unclear  as  flans  may  be  too 

imaTl . 


164 


CHINESE  CLOTH  CURRENCY 

R.  J.  Hebert y Washington , D.C.  USA. 

( Author's  Note:  Numbers  in  parentheses  are  from  R.  H.  Mathews' 

CHINESE- AMERICAN  DICTIONARY  (Harvard.  Univ.  Press 3 Cambridge 3 Mass  .1950 ) 
I am  indebted  to  the  staff  of  the  Freer  Gallery  Library  for  confir- 
ming these  readings . ) 


The  Szechuan-Shensi  Provincial  Soviet  Workers  and  Fanners  Bank  notes 
printed  on  cloth  of  various  colors  are  well  knov/n.  Not  so  well  known 
are  the  two  cloth  notes  from  the  National  Numismatic  Collection  illus- 
trated here. 


Figure  1:  Front  of  Note  ftl  Figure  2:  Back  of  Note  # 1 

The  legend  in  the  upper  left  corner  of  Note  #1  Obverse,  at  left,  is 
transliterated  as  CH'UAN  (#1445),  TSU  (#6927),  ERH  (#1752),  SHIN 
(#5807),  HAO  (2064),  and  they  could  be  translated  as:  "cash  strings," 
"property,  wealth,"  "two,"  "ten,"  and  "a  number." 

The  leaend  in  the  middle  of  the  same  note  transliterates  as:  FA  (#1768). 
P'lAO  (#5192),  CH'IEN  (#921),  I (#3016),  CH'OEN  (#1445) , WEN  ' (#7129c) , 
CHENG  (#356a) , YIN  (?) (#7432) , P'lAO  (#5192)  - or  "to  issue,  put. 


165 


or  send  forth,"  "bank  note,"  "monev,"  "one,"  "cash  strinns," 
"coins,"  "only,"  "silver,"  and  "bank  note." 

The  legend  of  the  upper  righthand  corner  of  Note  #1  transl i terates  as- 
CHIN  (#1006c) , SHEN  (#5712e),  I (#3016),  HCU  (#2 147a ) , SHENG 
(#5750),  CHAO ( ?) (#242a) , and  ??  The  translations  could  be  "nrice, 
value,"  "to  make  up  the  deficit  of  scale  or  value  in  weighing  silver, 
"secure,"  "residue,  surplus,  remnants,"  "to  pav  a balance,  to  ex- 
change," and  ??? 


Figure  4:  Back  of  Note  #2 

The  leoend  on  the  front  of  Note  #2  above,  reading  from  right  to  left 
is:  T 1 E (#6165),  SSU  (#5598),  SHIH  (#5807),  and  I (#3016),  or 

"special,"  "4,"  "10,"  and  "1".  Next  are  the  Uiahur  Turkic  words: 

IKI  "two,"  "MITHQAL,"  or  "one-tenth  of  a Chinese  ounce,  mace,"  while 
the  next  phrase  reads  ERH  (#1752),  CH'IEN  (#921),  or  "two,"  and  "one 
tenth  of  a Chinese  ounce,  mace."  The  next  phrase,  either  Mongol  or 
Manchu,  almost  surely  is  an  exact  translation  of  the  previous  Chinese 


166 


and  Uiohur  Turkic.  The  last  character,  to  the  far  left,  is  CHIU  or 
"nine" . 

The  phrase  on  the  back  of  the  note  #2,  possibly  Manchu  or  Monnol , remains 
unread . 

************************************************************************ 


CONG  I AR I A 


Although  congiaria  (gifts  to  the 
people  by  the  emperor)  were  not 
usually  given  unless  the  donor  was 
in  Rome,  we  have  medal  lie  proof 
that  this  restriction  was  waived  in 
the  case  of  Emperor  Macrinus.  This 
emperor  was  never  to  see  Rome  while 
he  held  the  purple,  but  he  did  in- 
gratiate himself  with  the  people 
even  with  the  treasury  depleted.  The  indulgence  of  Septimus  Severus 
and  the  prodigality  of  Caracalla  (the  two  preceding  emperors)  debili- 
tated the  whole  empire  till  the  days  of  Diocletian.  Macrinus  was  also 
obliged  to  promise  the  old  donative  of  5000  denarii  per  man  to  his 
Praetorians,  who  had  at  least  quadrupled  since  Caesar's  time  when 
the  practice  started,  when  he  proclaimed  his  son,  Diadumenianus , 
Augustus.  The  Praetorians  were  only  given  1000  denarii  in  hand,  and 
promised  the  rest  later,  while  the  soldiers  who  had  already  pocketed 
the  emperor's  first  gift  of  750  denarii,  were  enjoying  the  booty  from 
the  conquered  lands.  Macrinus  further  promised  at  this  time  a con- 
giary  of  150  denarii  to  each  of  the  people  of  Rome.  Such  was  the 
state  of  the  Roman  Empire  in  A.D.  218. 

(Submitted  by  R.  R.  Kutcher) 

★ ★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★  'k'k'k'k'k'k'k'k'k'k'k'k'k'k'k 

DEITY  COINS  OF  AUGUSTUS  STRUCK  BY  ROME  MINT 


The  first  Roman  Emperor,  Augustus, 
was  during  his  life-time  treated  as 
a deity.  He  had,  besides  altars 
and  temples,  his  own  priests,  and 
other  marbles  and  monuments  to  at- 
test to  the  divine  honours  paid  to 
the  living  Augustus.  However,  he 
did  not  permit  these  divine  honours 
to  be  paid  to  him  at  Rome.  He  al- 
lowed only  the  provinces  to  confer 
these  honours  on  him.  However, 
there  is  a series  of  coins  from  the 
Mint  of  Rome  with  the  reverse  in- 
scription "DIVVS  (the  mark  of  consecration)  AVGVSTVS  PATER  (father  - 
usually  given  after  death)".  Augustus  is  shown  in  a toga  with  a radiat- 
ed head  and  seated  next  to  an  altar  on  which  a small  flame  is  burning. 
He  holds  a branch  in  his  right  hand  and  rests  his  left  on  the  hasts 
pura.  The  coins  were  supposedly  struck  in  A.D.  22  and  issued  the 
24th  of  April  by  the  widow  of  Augustus,  Julia  Augusta. 

(Submitted  by  R.  R.  Kutcher) 

167 


THE  COINS  OF  SALTA,  ARGENTINA 

(An  exerpt  from  "Argentina,  A History  and  Coinage  1516-1880") 

J.  Aiwa  Ott , Provo,  Utah , NI  # 2145 

After  formally  declaring  their  independence  from  Spain  on  July  9,  1816, 
the  patriots  of  Argentina  had  many  internal  government  conflicts  and 
many  battles  yet  to  fight  as  the  young  country's  borders  were  being 
shaped  and  reshaped  into  what  they  are  today. 

One  of  these  border  battles  was  taking  place  in  the  northern  Argentine 
Province  of  Salta.  Ongoing  skirmishes  were  trading  land  in  the  north 
back  and  forth,  as  the  patriots  won  and  lost  battles  with  the  Spaniards. 
In  1816  the  patriots  had  just  lost  Potosi  (now  in  Bolivia)  for  a second 
devastating  time.  This  defeat  of  the  rich  silver  mines  of  Potosi  was 
a blow  to  the  Argentines  not  only  because  of  the  financial  benefits  it 
gave  the  patriots,  but  the  morale  of  the  soldiers  was  low  due  to  the 
ongoing  fighting.  Led  by  General  Marin  Guemes , they  retreated  back 
to  the  Province  of  Salta. 

Added  to  the  soldiers  burdens  was  the  fact  that  due  to  the  young  govern- 
ment's own  internal  conflicts  in  Buenos  Aires,  the  patriots  in  Salta 
were  ignored,  receiving  no  aid  - military  or  financial  - from  the 
government. 

It  was  extremely  difficult  for  General  Guemes  to  pay  his  troops  as 
there  was  very  little  or  no  national  coinage  circulating  in  Salta. 

What  was  circulating  was  counterfeit  Potosi  cobs,  and  the  act  of  pay- 
ing his  soldiers  in  phony  money  was  not  helping  their  morale  and 
there  were  many  desertions. 

In  1817  Guemes  developed  a monogram  that  spells  "PATRIA"  (Country) 
which  was  surrounded  by  a wreath  of  laurels.  He  counterstamped  this 
monogram  on  the  fake  cobs  and  guaranteed  them  as  genuine. 

Very  shortly  (in  fact  within  that  same  year)  the  government  in  Buenos 
Aires  discovered  what  Guemes  was  doing  and  declared  this  as  illegal. 

The  short-lived  coinage  fell  out  of  circulation.  This  act  of  counter- 
stamping, however,  gained  the  time  Guemes  needed  for  his  army  to  rid 
the  area  of  Spanish  influence. 

True  Salta  cobs  of  this  epoch  are  only  found  today  on  counterfeit 
Potosi  cobs  of  two,  four,  and  a newly  discovered  and  unlisted  eight 
reales.  The  two  reales  pieces  are  rare,  the  four  real  pieces  are 
extremely  rare,  and  there  is  only  one  known  example  of  the  eight  real 
piece  of  this  series. 

This  unique  eight  reales  piece  was  recently  discovered  by  the  renowned 
author  and  Museum  Director  of  the  Banco  Nacional  of  Argentina  in  Buenos 
Aires,  Arnaldo  J.  Cunietti -Ferrando , and  is  now  on  exhibit  in  that 
museum's  coin  collection.  (Illustrated  on  following  page.)  Also 
pictured  is  a two  real  piece  from  the  museum's  collection. 

Thanks  to  Mr.  Arnoldo  J.  Cunietti -Ferrando  and  the  Banco  Nacional  for 
the  courtesy  of  allowing  me  to  photograph  and  publish  the  photographs 
of  these  coins. 


168 


Counterfeit  Potosi  Cobs 

ND  (1817)  2 and  8 Reales  with  Salta  Counterstamp 


169 


CONTENTS  OF  THE  NI  REFERENCE  COLLECTION 

(Members  desiring  to  borrow  coins  from  the  collection  for  research 
purposes,  lecture  use,  non-competitive  displays,  or  any  other  reasons, 
may  do  so  by  paying  postage  and  insurance  both  directions.) 

Key  to  Listing:  FINE  or  better  for  all  Yeoman  types.  VERY  GOOD  or 
better  for  all  Criag  types.  Underlined  = Uncirculated.  C = Complete. 

C^  = Complete  with  at  least  one  uncirculated  type.  CX  ( ) = Com- 

plete except  those  listed.  X = Except.  Mints  are  not  listed  unless 
multiple  for  the  particular  year. 

GRENADA:  Y5  - C. 

GUADELOUPE:  Y1  - C;  Y2  - 1903. 

GUATEMALA:  Y36  - 1876;  Y42  - 1880,  1881,  1884,  1886;  Y45  - 1888;  Y47 

- 1889,  1890;  Y49  - 1893;  Y60  - 1880,  1890;  Y61a  - 1890;  Y74  - CX  (1893, 

1894H,  1899);  Y75  - 1894;  Y77  - 1898;  Y82  - 1895,  1896,  1898;  Y85  - C; 

Y86  - C;  Y87  - CX  (1911);  Y89  - C;  Y90  - C;  Y91  - C;  Y93  - C;  Y94  - C; 

Y96  - C;  Y97  CX  (1946,  1948,  1949);  Y98  - C;  Y99  - 1948,  1949;  Y100  - 
1925,  1944,  1948;  YlOOa  - CX  (1932,  1933,  1947);  Y102  - C;  Y1 02a  - 
1946;  Y108  - 1944;  Y109  - 1944;  Y110  - C;  Ylll  - CX  (1952,  1954); 

Yll 2 - C;  Y 11 3 - C;  Y114  - C;  Y115  - 1950,  1952;  Y116  - CX  (1964); 

Y117  - 1952,  1955;  Y117a  - 1957;  Y118  - 1964;  Y119  - 1950;  Y120  - 1964; 
Y121  - 1962;  Y122  CX  (1967,  1970);  Y1 22b  - 1974;  Y123  - CX  (1966, 
1969);  Y 1 23a  - 1975,  1978;  Y124  - CX  (1968);  Y125  - 1966;  Yl 25a  - 1969, 
1970. 

GUERNSEY:  YA1  - 1830;  YD1  - 1834;  Yla  - 1933,  1938;  Y2a  - 1929;  Y3  - 

1864;  Y3a  - 1949:  Y4  - 1885;  Y5  - 1934,  1938,  1949;  Y6  - 1956  ; Y9  - 

1966;  Y10  - 1971;  Yll  - 1971;  Y12  - 1971;  Y13  - 1968;  Y14  - 1970;  Yl 5 

- CX  (1971);  Yl 9 - 1977;  Y20  - 1977;  Y21  - 1977;  Y22  - 1977. 

GUINEA:  Yl  - C. 

GUINEA-BISSAU  - PORTUGUESE  GUINEA:  Yl  - C;  Y2  - C;  Y3  - C;  Y6  - C; 

Y7  - C;  Y8  - C;  Y9  - C. 

GUINEA-BISSAU:  Y3  - 1977;  Y4  - 1977. 

GUYANA  - BRITISH  GUIANA:  Y5  - 1943. 

GUYANA  - ESSEQUIBO  & DEMERARA:  C4  - C;  C5  - C: 

GUYANA:  Yl  - 1967;  Y2  - 1967;  Y3  - C;  Y4  - 1967,  1974;  Y5  - C;  Y6  - C. 

HAITI:  C7  - 1881,  1894;  C25  - 1817  lq.  head;  C31  - 1831,  C36  - 1829; 

C41~^  C;  C71  - C;  YA1  - C;  YB1  - C;  YC1  - C;  Y3  - C;  Y6  - 1887,  1894; 

Y7  - 1881,  1894;  Y10  - 1904,  1905;  Yll  - 1906;  Y12  - 1907;  Y13  - C; 

Yl 7 - C;  Y19  - C;  Y20  - 1958;  Y21  - 1958;  Y22  - C;  Y24  - 1975;  Y25  - 
1975;  Y26  - 1975. 

HONDURAS:  Y39  - CX  (1939)  Y40  - C;  Y41  - CX  (1972):  Y42  - 1956;  Y43  - 

CX  (1951) ; Y45  - 1937;  Y47  - 1967. 

HONG  KONG:  Yl  - CX  (1864);  Y2  - 1875;  Y2b  - 1879,  1901,  1901H;  Y3  - 

1887,  1889,  1891,  1899,  1900H,  1901;  Y4  - 1887,  1891,  1897,  1899,  1900H, 
1901;  Y7  - 1893,  1894;  Y9  - 1902,  1904H,  1905H;  Y10  - 1903,  1904;  Y14  - 
CX  (1919);  Yl 5 - CX  (1934);  Y17  - C;  Y18  - 1933;  Y21  - C;  Y22  - 1939H, 
1939KN;  Y23  - 1938,  1939H;  Y24  - C:  Y25  - C;  Y26  - C;  Y27  - C to  1967 
X (1964H);  Y27a  - 1971KN;  Y28  - CX  (1955,  1956,  1957H,  1957KN);  Y28a  - 
1974,  1975;  Y29  - CX  (1960,  1965KN,  1968H,  1970H);  Y29a  - 1 9 7 1 KM , 

1972  ; Y30  - C;  Y30a  - 1 971 H , 1972  , 1973;  Y33  - C to  1978  X (1976). 

170 


BOOK  REVIEWS 

Neumann,  Josef.  BESCHREIBUNG  DER  BEKANNTESTEN  KUPFERHUNZEN . 

and 

Neumann,  Josef.  THE  COPPER  COINS  OF  THE  LON  COUNTRIES , FRANCE , SPAIN 

AND  PORTUGAL 


A happy  generation  of  American  collectors  of  world  copper  coins  was 
brought  up  on  0.  P.  Eklund's  country-by-country  catalogues.  These  came 
out  serially  in  the  Numismatist  over  a 20-year  period.  Most  of  them 
were  later  reprinted  as  pamphlets.  They're  still  convenient,  uncompli- 
cated references.  Ole  Eklund's  principal  source  was  Neumann's  six-vol- 
ume 1858-1872  masterwork,  dealing  with  copper  (and  some  billon)  coins. 
The  work  was  rare  in  Eklund's  day.  It  is  equally  so  today,  even  in  a 
reprint  version  now  out  of  print. 

In  the  April  1987  N I Bulletin  appeared  the  welcome  announcement  of 
Michael  Robinson's  corrected,  supplemented  and  slightly  rearranged  re- 
print of  Neumann's  350-odd  Italian  pages  in  one  volume  and  the  300-odd 
pages  covering  France,  the  Low  Countries  and  Iberia  in  another.  The  two 
volumes  together  are  priced  at  £35  plus  postage  - a modest  figure  in 
view  of  the  very  limited  edition. 

However  useful  Eklund  is,  his  primary  source  is  far  more  so.  For  exam- 
ple, Eklund  devoted  less  than  a third  as  many  pages  as  Neumann  to 
Italian  coppers,  and  a third  of  Eklund's  space  is  taken  up  with  illus- 
trations. He  lists  some  1200  coins  - Neumann  over  5000.  Neumann's 
descriptions  are  fuller  and  clearer.  His  coverage  is  broader:  it  in- 
cludes tokens,  tesserae  and  some  monetary  weights  as  well  as  coins. 
Neumann's  scope  is  more  detailed  than  the  Krause-Mishler  "Phone  Book" 
for  the  material  they  both  cover.  In  addition  Neumann  extends  all  the 
way  back  to  the  beginning  of  each  national  coinage. 

These  two  volumes  are  all  of  Neumann  that  Dr.  Robinson  plans  to  reprint. 
His  choice  is  shrewdly  made.  The  Italian  section  is  one  of  Neumann's 
strongest,  and  it  handles  a noble  and  perennially  popular  series.  The 
other  volume  draws  between  two  covers  material  which  one  would  other- 
wise have  to  search  through  half  a dozen  incompatible  references  to  as- 
semble . 

As  a long-time  copper-coinage  enthusiast,  I should  like  to  register 
gratitude  and  admiration.  When  you  hold  Michael  Robinson's  product  in 
your  hand,  the  job  looks  deceptively  easy.  Few  realize,  for  example, 
what  painstaking  work  went  into  checking  and  correcting  hundreds  of 
textual  and  chronological  Inaccuracies.  In  addition  to  the  scholarly 
improvement,  the  production  involved  a daunting  amount  of  pure  drudgery, 
such  as  collating  some  tens  of  thousands  of  sheets,  all  done  by  the 
publisher  himself  in  an  effort  to  keep  the  unit  price  down. 

The  two  reprints  stand  on  their  own  as  an  important  numismatic  event. 
Specialists  will  welcome  them,  and  indeed  their  availability  will  re- 
cruit new  specialists.  In  addition,  they  exemplify  the  selfless  commit- 
ments that  public-spirited  colleagues  so  often  generously  take  on. 


171 


Reviewed  by  Randolph  Zander 


CUBA  - A COUNTRY  AND  ITS  CURRENCY.  National  Bank  of  Cuba,  Habana  (1986). 
227  pp,  illustrated  in  text.  23  x 34  cm.  Hardbound.  Available  from 
Ingrid  K.  Smith,  Box  865,  Adelaide  St.,  P.O.,  TORONTO,  Ontario  M5C  2K1, 
CANADA  for  $33.  postpaid. 


The  National  Bank  of  Cuba  has  produced  an  attractive  coffee-table  book 
presenting  an  overview  for  the  layman  of  almost  500  years  of  the  is- 
land's tempestuous  history.  The  book  brings  forward  coins,  medals,  bank- 
notes and  tokens  to  point  up  economic,  political  and  social  development. 

The  first  two  thirds  of  the  book  trace  events  from  Colombus'  sighting  of 
Cuba  up  to  1952.  The  remainder  is  devoted  to  a subjective  exposition  of 
Castro's  rise  to  power  and  of  Cuba  under  his  regime.  Understandably,  the 
presentation  fulfils  a propaganda  role;  the  question  is  whether  the 
reader,  screening  out  the  obvious  ''message,”  finds  the  residue  suffi- 
ciently informative  and  interesting.  On  balance  I think  it  likely  is. 
The  general  reader  is  better  served  than  the  person  who  is  looking  for 
detailed  numismatic  information.  The  narrative  flows  agreeably,  the  il- 
lustrations - especially  of  mid-19th  century  life  - catches  the  eye,  and 
so  do  the  fine  numismatic  illustrations,  mostly  of  banknotes  and  mostly 
in  color.  One  not  very  well  known  curiosity  is  a group  of  six  provision- 
al playing-card  improvisations  as  money,  along  the  lines  of  the  better 
known  Canadian  example.  These  come  from  Santiago  de  Cuba  and  date  from 
the  1780s. 

If  the  numismatic  reader  is  looking  chiefly  for  "context,”  the  book  pro- 
vides it  in  easily  digestible  doses.  The  Bank  has  worked  up  three  ver- 
sions, in  Spanish,  English  and  French.  The  book  is  well  printed  by  the 
Paris  firm  of  Editions  Sand. 


Reviewed  by  Randolph  Zander 


Edward  C.  Rochette.  MAKING  MONEY:  Rogues  & Rascals  Mho  Made  Their 
Own. 1986.  150  pp.,  75  photos.  23  x 15  cm.  Paperback.  $9.95  from  the 
publisher.  Renaissance  House,  P.  0.  Box  177,  Frederick,  CO  80530. 


Readers  of  Ed  Rochette 's  vignettes  in  COINage  and  Numismatic  News  will 
recognize  some  of  the  100  of  them  now  gathered  in  this  handy  paperback. 
This  group  focuses  on  counterfeiters,  forgers,  fantasists  and  con-men, 
many  of  them  with  schemes  so  outlandish  and  execution  so  bungled  that 
one  is  driven  to  sympathy. 

Ed  Rochette 's  crisp  style  and  well  chosen  pictures  make  this  a lively 
anthology.  Much  of  the  contents  qualifies  as  light  reading,  but  there 
are  as  well  useful  background  sketches  on  such  subjects  as  Carl  Becker, 
the  18th  century  master  die-sinker;  William  Walker's  Nicaraguan  script; 
Martin  Coles  Harmon  and  his  Lundy  puffins;  and  the  Hutt  River  currency. 

This  book  is  a companion  to  last  year's  Rochette  anthology  The  Other 
Side  of  the  Coin  put  out  by  the  same  publisher. 

Reviewed  by  Randolph  Zander 


172 


LES  MONNAIES  DE  LA  PRINCIPAUTE  DE  LIEGE.  A.  Mignolet.  125pp.,  55 
plates.  Paperback.  Maastricht,  1986.  US$31.  postpaid  from:  A.  G.  van 
der  Dussen,  Hondstraat  5,  6211  HU  Maastricht , Netherlands. 

- and  - 

CATALOGUE. .DES  MONNAIES  ET  MEDAILLES  (COLLECTION  PIAT) . Dupriez,  Brus- 
sels, 1910.  25pp.  + 5 plates,  530  lots.  Reprint  by  A.  Mignolet. 
Paperback.  Available  at  US$14.  also  from  A.G.  van  der  Dussen  at  the 
above  address. 


Just  a hundred  years  ago  Baron  Jules  Chestret  de  Haneffe  brought  out 
his  great  standard  work  on  the  complex  coinage  of  the  Principality  of 
Li&ge  and  its  dependencies  extending  over  eight  centuries.  Chestret 
added  a 1900  supplement,  and  other  authors  refined  his  coverage  here  or 
there,  but  the  basic  work  has  stood  the  test  of  time.  Guy  Genard's 
1972  reprint  of  the  work  is  now  out  of  print,  and  the  original  of 
course  is  very  rare. 

Andr&  Mignolet  now  presents  an  ingenious  new  version.  It  reproduces  55 
plates  of  line  cuts,  in  general  more  sharply  than  the  1972  reprint.  In 
place  of  the  original's  466  pages  of  history,  biographical  data,  laws 
and  ordinances  as  well  as  actual  descriptions  of  the  coins,  Mignolet 
furnishes  125  pages  of  purely  descriptive  catalogue  text,  keyed  to  the 
plates.  Every  item  is  illustrated.  Many  of  Chestret's  references  are 
superseded  by  newer  ones,  the  occasional  is  put  right,  and  the  dis- 
coveries of  the  past  85  years  are  woven  into  the  catalogue.  An  im- 
portant feature  is  Mignolet's  indications  of  relative  rarity  for  vir- 
tually every  item.  At  a realistic  price  this  new  work  brings  within 
the  range  of  the  interested  collector  the  main  substance  of  Chestret's 
actual  catalogue. 


In  1910,  scarcely  a year  after  Chestret's  death,  Charles  Dupriez  held 
in  Brussels  an  auction  which  included  the  celebrated  Li&ge  series  of  A. 
Piat.  The  Lifcgeois  element  ran  to  over  500  lots  with  five  plates.  It 
featured  numerous  unique  pieces  and  great  rarities.  The  great  majority 
of  Chestret's  700-odd  numbers  were  represented.  This  catalogue  has 
been  almost  as  rare  as  Chestret's  work,  to  which  it  is  a valuable  ac- 
companiment. Mignolet  has  accordingly  reproduced  the  Lidgeois  pages, 
together  with  an  exceptionally  sharp  rendition  of  the  plates.  There  is 
as  well  a list  of  prices  realized. 

The  price  of  US$14.  for  25  pages  plus  5 plates  may  seem  stiff.  But 
reproducing  plates  in  this  quality  doesn't  come  cheap;  and  the  small 
edition  imposes  a high  unit  price. 


These  two  items  are  available  to  NI  members  from  the  Library. 

Reviewed  by  Randolph  Zander 


173 


Jerry  F.  Schimmel.  GERMAN  TOKENS,  Part  I.  San  Francisco  1987.  85  pp. 

incl . , 10  plates.  Paperback,  21.5  x 14  cm.  $8.00  postpaid  from  the 
author  at  P.  0.  Box  40888,  San  Francisco,  CA  94140. 

The  present  catalogue  is  the  first  of  two  installments.  This  one  deals 
with  purely  German  tokens.  Part  II  will  handle  the  tokens  of  German- 
speaking regions  - Austria,  Luxembourg,  Switzerland  &c.  The  700-odd 
items  listed  are  intended  to  include  essentially  all  commercial  tokens 
except  Notgeld.  It  is  helpful  that  almost  a third  of  them  are  illus- 
trated. The  catalogue's  main  body  is  arranged  alphabetically  by  city; 
in  addition  there  are  sections  devoted  to  stock  tokens,  to  mavericks, 
and  to  numerals  and  designs.  The  10  plates  of  illustrations  however 
are  arranged  according  to  a different  set  of  categories,  and  the  basic 
listing  does  not  indicate  which  items  are  listed.  The  result  is  that 
the  reader  is  left  to  some  extent  to  grope  his  way. 

Important  aids  are  a bibliography,  a two-way  13-pp.  index,  some  shrewd 
observations  on  pricing  and  rarity,  hints  on  dating  German  tokens,  and 
a short  list  of  dealers  sympathetic  to  the  subject. 

Two  things  have  to  be  kept  in  mind:  (1)  the  pamphlet's  subject  includes 
many  ambiguous,  ephemeral  and  unclear  items,  and  (2)  the  pamphlet  it- 
self is  designed  to  serve  as  a practical  working  guide  rather  than  a 
definitive  coverage.  Given  the  aim  and  the  circumstances,  it  succeeds 
very  satisfactorily.  This  is  not  surprising  since  the  author  is  a 
specialist  in  tokens  and  already  has  various  books  and  articles  to  his 
credit.  The  present  one  should  add  to  his  renown. 

Reviewed  by  Randolph  Zander 


200  JAHRE  SCHWEINFURTER  VOGELS CHUSS.  R.  Jordan,  Editor.  Schweinfurt 
1987.  86pp , ill  us . (not  for  sale,  but  there  is  a copy  in  the  NI  Lib- 
rary) . 

This  pamphlet  traces  the  200-year  history  of  the  VOGELSCHUSS  - a form 
of  marksmanship  competition  involving  a target  surmounted  by  an  her- 
aldic eagle  - in  the  old  Bavarian  town  of  Schweinfurt.  It  is  richly 
illustrated  and  provides  an  appealing  account  (in  German)  of  a popular 
and  still  very  active  tradition. 

Of  numismatic  interest  are  the  numerous  pictures  of  shooting  medals, 
plagues,  etc.  which  are  catalogued  as  well.  Also  shown  and  described 
are  several  S chut zenket ten  - interwoven  complexes  of  dizens  of  indi- 
vidual medals,  badges,  prices,  etc.  - belonging  to  outstanding  marks- 
men and  to  Vogetschuss  officials  past  and  present. 

Reviewed  by  Randolph  Zander 


Yoshinori  Ogawa , Hitoshi  Kozono,  and  Col.  Joseph  E,  Boling,  PAPER 
MONEY  OF  THE  20th  CENTURY , PAPER  MONEY  OF  JAPAN , VOLUME  4B%  163pp, 

i 1 1 us . The  looseleaf  format  is  printed  to  fit  into  the  three  ring 
binder  supplied  with  Section  A of  Volume  4,  The  book  without  the 


174 


binder  is  available  for  $17.50  postpaid,  or  Volume  4 A and  B with 
binder  may  be  ordered  for  $36.50  from  Alfred  Hortmann  at  P,  0,  Box 
11874,  Clayton,  Missouri  63105  (postpaid). 

At  long  last  the  awaited  I.B.N.S.  series  PAPER  MOREY  OF  THE  20th 
CENTURY , VOLUME  4B.  PAPER  MONEY  OF  JAPAN  has  been  published  to  con- 
tinue section  A published  in  1981,  The  authors  have  done  a masterful 
job  of  listing  the  military  notes  of  the  Japanese  Empire. 

A big  disappointment  was  not  finding  the  Japanese  puppet  banks  in 
China  and  the  other  overseas  bank  issues.  However,  as  the  intro- 
duction states,  those  listings  were  considered  more  appropriate  for  a 
future  catalog  of  China  and  Korea. 

The  military  notes  from  1894  of  the  Si  no-Japanese  War  all  the  way  thru 
the  Greater  East  Asia  War  period  ending  in  1945  are  treated  in  depth 
with  many  new  unpublished  facts  as  to  note  production,  circulation 
and  disposition  as  well  as  watermarks  and  areas  used. 

JIMs,  or  Japanese  Invasion  Money  notes,  are  fully  covered  including 
their  after  use  such  as  the  Mazakar  note  overprints  of  the  Netherlands 
East  Indies  series  and  the  overprints  of  the  Japanese  War  Motes 
Claimants  Association  in  the  Philippines. 

A wholly  new  area  is  covered  by  the  Prisoner  of  War  and  Internment 
Camp  Notes  chapter.  These  very  scarce  and  little  known  numismatic 
mementos  are  published  for  the  very  first  time  as  far  as  this  re- 
viewer knows.  Very  helpful  is  a listing  of  the  POW  camps  operated 
by  the  Japanese  during  World  War  II  and  a map  showing  their  locations. 
In  addition  there  are  four  appendix  pages  amplifying  the  areas  and 
camp  listings. 

A surprise  in  the  ANC  (Allied  Military  Currency)  chapter  are  the  pro- 
visional currency  chits  issued  for  Kume  Island.  Even  after  more  than 
forty  years  following  WW  II  new  items  keep  appearing.  The  Foreign 
Trade  Payment  Certificates  are  well  illustrated  and  documented. 

British  Commonwealth  Occupation  Force  chits  are  introduced  as  are 
the  U.  S.  Force  Club  chits.  These  are  a little  known  or  collected 
field  of  the  paper  money  hobby.  The  Allied  propaganda  notes  are 
also  listed. 

The  last  chapter  covers  the  issues  of  the  Yokohama  Spcie  Bank  and 
its  nine  note  issuing  branches.  Illustrated  closeups  of  some  of 
the  key  characters  and  vignettes  are  shown  and  are  most  helpful. 

Reviewed  by  Angus  E.  Bruce 

************+*********** ******************  k ************************** 

BALISTA 


Balista  was  one  of  the  short-lived  usurpers  during  the  reign  of  Gal- 
lienus.  He  was  proclaimed  Emperor  in  Syria  in  262  A.D.  but  he  was 
slain  there  in  264.  All  of  the  coins  bearing  his  name  have  proved 
to  be  false. 


(Submitted  by  R.  R.  Kutcher) 


175 


MEMBER  NOTICE  PAGE 

Paul  Waichulai ti s , P.  0,  Box  213,  Waupaca,  WI  54981:  WANTED  - German 

States' minors  for  research.  Looking  for  overdates  and  other  common 
errors  on  the  most  common  pieces.  Willing  to  buy  at  up  to  40  to  50% 
of  catalog,  or  will  trade  other  world  coins  if  I have  them  available. 
Please  write  if  you  think  you  have  anything  of  interest, 

B.  F.  Brekke,  Box  304 , Chapal a , Jal . MEXICO:  Specialized  collector  of 

Russian  copper  coins  1700-1917  is  interested  in  receiving  list  or 
auction  catalogues  containing  larger  groups  or  especially  rare  specimens 

ATTRIBUTION  SERVICE:  The  NI  Attribution  Committee  will  accept  from  NI 

members  only,  any  numismatic  items,  whether  paper,  metal,  or  whatever, 
for  attribution.  We  must  limit  the  items  to  a TOTAL  OF  SIX  (6)  MAXI- 
MUM. The  cost  is  just  advance  payment  of  return  postage,  including 
sufficient  for  insurance  or  registration,  if  desired.  Send  to  NI 
Attribution  Committee,  P.  0.  Box  2057,  Saugatuck  Station,  Westport, 

Conn.  06880,  USA. 

*********************************************************************** 
DENARIUS  SYMBOLIZES  FILIAL  PIETY 


Two  brothers  from  Sicily,  Amphinomus  and  Anapis, 
are  reported  by  the  ancients  to  have  saved  their 
parents,  at  the  peril  of  their  own  lives,  from  the 
flames  of  the  volcanic  eruption  of  Etna.  This  was 
a favorite  subject  with  the  ancients,  in  symbol- 
izing filial  piety,  and  is  often  represented  on 
Greek  and  Roman  coins.  A denarius  of  Trajan  ex- 
hibits on  its  reverse  Neptune  in  the  center  of  the  group,  and  two 
naked  young  men  carrying  on  their  shoulders  aged  figures,  one  either 
side.  This  is  the  Roman  example  of  the  Greek  brothers  rescuing  their 
father  and  their  mother  from  the  burning  mountain. 

(Submitted  by  R.  R.  Kutcher) 

********************************************************************** 


D_' 'Q]JAD RJ  G ATJ  COINAGE 


Bigati  are  a class  of  Roman  silver 
coins,  so  called  from  the  reverse 
type  with  a chariot  drawn  by  two 
horses.  It  was  a long  time  before 
portraits  of  living  persons  were 
placed  on  Roman  coins.  For  cen- 
turies the  denarii  of  the  Republic 
had  on  its  obverse  the  head  of  Roma 
or  of  Pallas.  The  reverse  showed  a figure  of  Victory  standing  in  a 
cart  drawn  by  two  or  by  four  horses.  Thus  they  were  called  "Biqati" 
and  "Quadrigati " . 


(Submitted  by  R.  R.  Kutcher) 


176